Also know as Graveyard Hill Cemetery. 1.7 miles north of Guthrie on Rte J., Callaway Co., Missouri. If you drive north from Guthrie, watch closely on the right side of the road. You can see the sign from the road, posted on a tree on a hill. You can pull off the road just past the cemetery and walk back into the woods to find the headstones.
This is not a complete listing of burials.
| Name | Headstone | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Allen, Jane Gamble | Photo | Jane G., stone is sunken into the ground, rest unreadable. It was located next to Rev. James Criswell and the Jane G. is readable, so assuming this was his wife, Jane Gamble Allen. She was a daughter of Joseph Allen and Mary Margaret... |
| Comer, Martha Ann | Photo | Martha A., wife of J.D. Nevins. Martha Ann Comer was a daughter of John A. Comer and Nancy McGary. She was born abt. 1836 and died abt. 1866. On Mar. 26, 1856 in Callaway Co., Missouri, she married Joseph D. Nevins. |
| Criswell, James Jr., Rev. | Photo | Rev. James Criswell, Jr., born abt. 1806, died abt. 1861. On Oct. 15, 1835 in Callaway Co., Missouri, he married my 2nd great grandaunt, Jane Gamble Allen. |
| Criswell, Jane Gamble Allen | Photo | Jane G., stone is sunken into the ground, rest unreadable. It was located next to Rev. James Criswell and the Jane G. is readable, so assuming this was his wife, Jane Gamble Allen. She was a daughter of Joseph Allen and Mary Margaret... |
| Criswell, Martha A. H. Hudson | Photo | Martha A. H. Hudson Criswell, 1st wife of Robert Wesley Criswell. Born Dec. 26, 1837 Died Sept. 1, 1857. Married Robert Wesley Criswell Oct. 15, 1856 in Callaway Co., Missouri. |
| Criswell, Nancy (Evens) | - | 31 Oct 1798 - 7 Apr 1893; w/o Robert Criswell |
| Criswell, Robert | - | 1793 - 20 Feb 1860; s/o James Criswell Sr. & Sarah Mackennon; h/o Nancy Evens |
| Criswell, Robert H | - | Abt 1849 - 13 Feb 1923; s/o George Criswell & Elizabeth Fitzhugh |
| Criswell, Sarah J | - | 27 May 1843 - 14 May 1879; d/o James Criswell Jr & Jane Gamble Allen |
| Criswell, Tan | Photo | Tan Criswell son of R.W. & E.A. Criswell, Born & Died Apr. 1859. Tan Criswell, was a son of Robert Wesley Criswell and Eliza Ann Holt. He was a grandson of Robert Criswell and Nancy Evens, and, Hiram Holt and Nancy Stanfield. He was my 1st... |
| Dickson, Margery Winifred | - | 22 Jul 1774 - 1845; w/o John D. Nevins |
| Dunavant, Catherine J. | Photo | Catherine J. Dunavant, daughter of J.C. & M.R. Dunavant. Died July 22, 1872, Aged 3 y 4 m 13 d. Catherine J. Dunavant was a daughter of Josephus C. Dunavant and Melissa R. Nevins. She was a granddaughter of Thomas Nevins and Catherine... |
| Evens, Nancy | - | 31 Oct 1798 - 7 Apr 1893; w/o Robert Criswell |
| Fisher, Mary Jane | Photo | Mary J. Nevins, wife of John D. Nevins, Died Sep. 10, 1846 Aged 28 ys 3 mo 4 ds Jun 6, 1818. Mary Jane Fisher was a daughter of Thomas Fisher and Isabella Humphreys. On Sep. 5, 1838 in Callaway Co., Missouri, she married John Nevins. |
| Foster, Nannie E. | Photo | Nannie E., dau. of G.T. & M.A. Foster, Died Oct. 12, 1875, aged 2 yrs 9 ms 30 dys. Nannie E. Foster was a daughter of George T. Foster and Martha Ann Guthrie. She was a granddaughter of Samuel Taylor Guthrie and Sarah Phillips. |
| Guthrie, Addison B. | Photo | Addison B., son of Thos F. & M.E. Guthrie, Died Jan. 12, 1863 Aged 2 yr 6 ds. Addison B. Guthrie was a son of Thomas Franklin Guthrie and Mary Elizabeth Clatterbuck. He was a grandson of Samuel Taylor Guthrie and Sarah Phillips, and,... |
| Guthrie, Ann S. (Nichols) | - | 20 Dec 1837 - 14 Jun 1869; d/o Felix G. Nichols & Elizabeth Ann Renoe; w/o (20 Feb 1856) Samuel Newton Guthrie |
| Guthrie, Charles P. | Photo | Charles P. son of S.T. & S. Guthrie. Born and Died Apr. 5, 1847. Charles P. Guthrie was a son of Samuel Taylor Guthrie and Sarah Phillips. |
| Guthrie, Felix | Photo | Felix R. Guthrie, son of S.N. and A. Guthrie, Born Nov. 20, 1858 Died Dec. 16, 1860. Felix Guthrie was a son of Samuel Newton Guthrie and Ann S. Nichols. He was a grandson of Samuel Taylor Guthrie and Sarah Phillips, and, Felix Nichols and... |
| Guthrie, Harriet E | - | 8 Sep 1842 - 11 Nov 1842; d/o Samuel Taylor Guthrie & Sarah (Sally) Phillips |
| Guthrie, Margaret | Photo | Margaret daughter of S.T. & S. Guthrie. Born and Died Apr. 17, 1836. Margaret Guthrie was a daughter of Samuel Taylor Guthrie and Sarah Phillips. |
| Guthrie, Samuel Newton | - | 8 Sep 1829 - Aft 1873; s/o Samuel Taylor Guthrie & Sarah (Sally) Phillips; h/o (20 Feb 1856) Ann S. Nichols, (11 May 1871) Lydia E. Mirts |
| Guthrie, Sarah Elizabeth | Photo | Sarah E. Holman, wife of Wm. H. Holman, Born Dec. 26, 1831 Died Feb. 24, 1859. Sarah Elizabeth Guthrie was a daughter of Samuel Taylor Guthrie and Sarah Phillips. On Apr. 29, 1857 in Callaway Co., Missouri, she married William Henry... |
| Holman, Sarah Elizabeth Guthrie | Photo | Sarah E. Holman, wife of Wm. H. Holman, Born Dec. 26, 1831 Died Feb. 24, 1859. Sarah Elizabeth Guthrie was a daughter of Samuel Taylor Guthrie and Sarah Phillips. On Apr. 29, 1857 in Callaway Co., Missouri, she married William Henry... |
| Howdershell, Mary | Photo | Mary Nevins, wife of Joseph Nevins, Died January 26, 1892 aged 88y 9m 5d. Mary Howdershell married Joseph Nevins. |
| Hudson, Martha A. H. | Photo | Martha A. H. Hudson Criswell, 1st wife of Robert Wesley Criswell. Born Dec. 26, 1837 Died Sept. 1, 1857. Married Robert Wesley Criswell Oct. 15, 1856 in Callaway Co., Missouri. |
| Humphreys, Elizabeth Nevins | Photo | I believe the last name is Humphreys, headstone is worn away and mostly unreadable. I think this is Elizabeth Nevins Humphreys, abt. 1800 - Mar. 27, 1865. She was a daughter of John D. Nevins and Margery Winfield Dickson. She married... |
| Humphreys, Richard | Photo | Richard Humphreys, Died July 17, 1839, aged 51 years. Richard Humphreys married Elizabeth Nevins. |
| McCutchen, Nancy E. | Photo | Nancy E. Nevins, wife of James Nevins. Nancy E. McCutchen was born Mar. 21, 1798 in Virginia, died Sept. 18, 1867, in Callaway Co., Missouri. She married James Nevins. |
| Nevins, Elizabeth | Photo | I believe the last name is Humphreys, headstone is worn away and mostly unreadable. I think this is Elizabeth Nevins Humphreys, abt. 1800 - Mar. 27, 1865. She was a daughter of John D. Nevins and Margery Winfield Dickson. She married... |
| Nevins, Henry W. | - | 31 Jul 1856 - 20 Nov 1866; s/o Thomas Nevins & Catherine Randolph |
| Nevins, James Baxter | Photo | James Nevins, Born Jan. 29, 1798 in Virginia, Died Jan. 8, 1861, Callaway Co., Missouri. James Baxter Nevins was a son of John D. Nevins and Margery Winifred Dickson. He married Nancy E. McCutchen. |
| Nevins, John B. | Photo | John B. Nevins son of J & M Nevins, Died Jun 3, 1843, Aged 14 y. 2 m. 2 d. Apr. 1, 1829 - June 3, 1843. John B. Nevins was a son of Joseph Nevins and Mary unknown. He was a grandson of John D. Nevins and Margery Winifred Dickson. |
| Nevins, John D. | Photo | John Nevins, Died Jan. 18, 1854 aged 97 years. Born abt. 1757. John D. Nevins married Margery Winifred Dickson. |
| Nevins, Joseph | - | 3 Nov 1794 - 8 Feb 1850; s/o John D. Nevins & Margery Winifred Dickson; h/o Mary Howdershell? |
| Nevins, Margery Winifred (Dickson) | - | 22 Jul 1774 - 1845; w/o John D. Nevins |
| Nevins, Martha Ann Comer | Photo | Martha A., wife of J.D. Nevins. Martha Ann Comer was a daughter of John A. Comer and Nancy McGary. She was born abt. 1836 and died abt. 1866. On Mar. 26, 1856 in Callaway Co., Missouri, she married Joseph D. Nevins. |
| Nevins, Mary Howdershell | Photo | Mary Nevins, wife of Joseph Nevins, Died January 26, 1892 aged 88y 9m 5d. Mary Howdershell married Joseph Nevins. |
| Nevins, Mary Jane Fisher | Photo | Mary J. Nevins, wife of John D. Nevins, Died Sep. 10, 1846 Aged 28 ys 3 mo 4 ds Jun 6, 1818. Mary Jane Fisher was a daughter of Thomas Fisher and Isabella Humphreys. On Sep. 5, 1838 in Callaway Co., Missouri, she married John Nevins. |
| Nevins, Nancy E. McCutchen | Photo | Nancy E. Nevins, wife of James Nevins. Nancy E. McCutchen was born Mar. 21, 1798 in Virginia, died Sept. 18, 1867, in Callaway Co., Missouri. She married James Nevins. |
| Nichols, Ann S. | - | 20 Dec 1837 - 14 Jun 1869; d/o Felix G. Nichols & Elizabeth Ann Renoe; w/o (20 Feb 1856) Samuel Newton Guthrie |
| Renoe, Priscilla Missouri A. | - | 20 May 1859 - 5 Mar 1872; d/o James Monroe Renoe & Evaline Boyd |
| Scott, Elizabeth (Unknown) | - | 20 Nov 1807 - 11 Mar 1870; w/o James Monroe Scott |
| Scott, James Monroe | - | 20 May 1803 - 29 Mar 1864; s/o William B Scott Sr & Unknown Hawthorn; h/o Elizabeth Unknown |
| Scott, Martha A. | - | 16 Jul 1831 - 18 Jul 1832; d/o James Monroe Scott & Elizabeth Unknown |
| Scott, Samuel B. | - | 30 Apr 1838 - 21 Sep 1863; s/o James Monroe Scott & Elizabeth Unknown |
| Unknown, Elizabeth | - | 20 Nov 1807 - 11 Mar 1870; w/o James Monroe Scott |
Back to Virtual Cemetery Index
Albemarle to Callaway Index
Copyright 1998 - 2011
This page updated Monday, 8 August 2011
